Assignment 2: Web Site Evaluation Critera
|
Organization *Whether the site has a clear hierarchy, and if so, whether it is narrow and deep or broad and shallow *Whether a consistent ("controlled") vocabulary is used throughout the site Navigation *Are navigational controls clearly visible and consistent in placement? *Can you quickly move to other parts of the site, without having to "back out"? *Does it use "mystery meat" navigation (see http://www.webpagesthatsuck.com/), or can you immediately tell where icons will take you? *Is there one navigational system, or more? (e.g global and local). *If frames are used, do they enhance or detract from identifying current location and/or navigating to other sections? *If hidden navigation (e.g. pull-down/pop-up menus) are used, is it clear that the information is available? *Is there any kind of table of contents or site map to provide a "bird's-eye view" of the site? Labeling *Is the labelling systematic, or random? (p. 74-75) *Do labels contradict or draw from current naming conventions (e.g. will "search" do what people expect? will "home" take them where they expect to go?) *Are ad hoc links clear, or confusing? (p. 96) Searching *Is it clear how to search? (syntax, use of boolean operators, etc) *Is sufficient information provided on the results screen (whether or not there are hits)? *Are results accurate and/or relevant? *How are errors (misspellings, etc) treated? |